Sunday, June 12, 2022

#52Ancestors - Week 23 - Mistake

The discussion in Week 23 of #52Ancestors is Mistakes, and they are oh so easy to make.  As discussed in Week 14 - Check it out, one of the biggest mistakes we can make as researchers is to blindly accept as fact anything we see in someone else's online family tree or in a database or archive.  Any new piece of information needs to be checked and confirmed.  Mistakes WILL be made - by researchers, by transcribers and digitizing projects, even by those who originally created records.

In my earlier post I listed some of the things to keep in mind to help spot obvious errors - and I have seen all of these in online trees : 

  • Children cannot be born before their parents. 
  • Children cannot be born to a mother who is 6 years old.  Or 94 years old.  
  • Children are highly unlikely to be born to a father who is 89 years old.  While this MAY be biologically possible, it is unlikely and deserves a bit of fact checking. 
  • A child cannot be christened 2 months before they are born. 
  • A woman cannot marry 3 years after she has died. 
  • A man cannot enlist in the army 5 years after he has died.

Recently I discovered a transcribed record in an online database that illustrated the mistakes that can occur.  The record for the baptism of Hannah May below leapt out at me when I first located it.  Why??  Check the birth and baptism dates again.  According to this record Hannah was born 17 August 1796 but baptised6 weeks earlier on 9 July 1796.

Something has been transcribed incorrectly in this record.  Possibly the dates are transposed and Hannah was born in July and baptised in August.  Possibly one of the months was transcribed incorrectly.  With no original image to check, I will need to dig further to find out.  It is clear, however, that a mistake has been made somewhere.

No comments:

Post a Comment